A client recently came to us with a key opening. They wanted someone with strong technical skills who could take ownership in the first week. It was a reasonable ask, especially with a team that was already stretched.
We hear some version of this from employers across industries. It makes sense for anyone company to look for someone who can step in right away. When it becomes the default, though, it raises a bigger question.
If every company wants to hire someone who’s already been trained, who’s doing the training?
The Experience Catch-22
Take a construction company hiring a Project Manager. It wants someone who has managed budgets, subcontractors, schedules, and client relationships on large jobs. A strong Assistant Project Manager may already handle much of that work under a Senior Project Manager. To learn how to run the whole job, they need someone to trust them.
The same pattern shows up in law firms, accounting departments, and operations teams. When fewer companies give people room to step up, more employers end up competing for the same pool of experienced candidates.
Which Experience Do You Really Need?
Say you’re hiring an Operations Manager to lead a team of 15. One candidate has supervised 8 people and managed a smaller budget. They’ve also taken on more responsibility each year, shown sound judgment in tough personnel situations, and helped cut order turnaround time.
How much does the difference between 8 and 15 matter? It depends on what the new hire will need to handle on their own and what support your team can give them.
In our experience, four questions help clarify what to look for before you set a minimum number of years or require a specific background.
- What does this person need to own on day one?
- What could they learn in the first three to six months?
- Where have they already shown they can take on more responsibility?
- Who on your team has time to help them get up to speed?
That last question can change who you’re able to hire. If you find someone who’s ready for a bigger role, decide how your team will support them before you make the offer.
How to Help Someone Step Into a Bigger Role
- Define success for the first 90 days. Set clear expectations for what the new hire should be able to handle at 30, 60, and 90 days.
- Name a go-to person. Choose someone who has time to answer questions, review early work, and give feedback.
- Expand responsibility as they’re ready. A new Project Manager might start by owning one project budget, with a Senior Project Manager reviewing it weekly.
- Revisit compensation as the role grows. Tie the pay review to meaningful changes in what the person owns.
When a search is dragging on, ask what it would cost to leave the role open for another three months and what it would take to support someone who’s ready to step up.
Sometimes you need someone who’s done the job before. The experienced Project Manager, Controller, or HR Director you’d like to hire today was once ready to take on more responsibility.
Someone gave them that chance.
If your search has stalled, revisit what the new hire needs to own on day one. We help clients identify which qualifications are essential and where a strong candidate is ready to take the next step.





